Reclaiming Our Shared Roots

Jesus, his family, and his earliest followers were all Jews, deeply appreciative of their religious heritage and eager to draw from it. How could it happen that, within a few generations, many Christians would fail to regard the Old Testament as essential to the faith?

Why Christians Need the Old Testament and Judaism

Today’s response to the first reading (Sirach) is Psalm 119, which prays that we live our lives in accord with God’s word. The psalm celebrates God’s word as relational, making possible communication between God and human beings. Both Sirach and Psalm 119 are from the Old Testament, which many Christians unfortunately dismiss and regard as exclusively Jewish, useful chiefly as background to the New Testament. Such dismissal makes it impossible to understand Paul’s letter to the Corinthians and Jesus’s Sermon on the Mount. Jesus, his family, and his earliest followers were all Jews, deeply appreciative of their religious heritage and eager to draw from it. How could it happen that, within a few generations, many Christians would fail to regard the Old Testament as essential to the faith?  

Mainstream Judaism’s rejection of Jesus and his messianic claims opened the door to an adversarial relationship only partially offset by continuing Christian respect for the Old Testament as divinely inspired. Tragically, at the onset of the second millennium, Christian anti-Judaism turned truly lethal, sometimes isolating Jews and inflicting on them deadly attacks and pogroms decimating entire villages. As the third millennium begins, Catholics have the opportunity to make up for past injustice and follow the lead of a history-making 1965 document of the Second Vatican Council Nostra aetate, A Declaration on the Relation of the Church to Non-Christian Religions: “Since Christians and Jews have such a common spiritual heritage, this sacred Council wishes to encourage mutual understanding and appreciation. This can be obtained, especially, by way of biblical and theological enquiry and through friendly discussions.” Scholars today are increasingly inclined to say that Rabbinic Judaism and Christianity are not parent and child but siblings whose parents are first- and second-century Judaism and earlier phases of the religion of Israel. The oft made and erroneous claim that Christianity replaced Judaism was never true historically, for Judaism continued to live and to spread long after Christianity appeared, and flourishes to this day. Christians can acquire an accurate view how their religion originated in Judaism only if they familiarize themselves with the rich Jewish literature of the late Second Temple and early rabbinic periods of Jewish history.

Richard Clifford, S.J., has taught biblical studies for 55 years, most recently at the Clough School of Theology and Ministry, Boston College, and has written many scholarly and popular books and articles.
 

Comments

0 Comments