It’s no longer politics; it’s immorality

Tom Dwyer with a sign at the No Kings protest

By Tom Dwyer, President & Executive Director of AFTDJ

The No Kings Rally sign read:

“It’s No Longer A Difference In Political Opinion; It’s a Difference in Morality.”

Perfect, I thought.  That is why my wife and I are here on Boston Common, a place laden with historic implications for democracy and resistance, with our sign, borrowed from a fellow AFTDJ leader, that read: ‘“When tyranny replaces justice, it is our duty to protest’ – Thomas Jefferson.”

Indeed, and very sadly, it is abundantly clear now, nine full months into the Trump administration, that our government has become explicitly immoral in the way that it continuously, arrogantly, and egregiously violates the foundational principles and values found in the holy writings and beliefs of our faith traditions, let alone our Constitution.

Last week in this space we published three short essays – one each from the Islamic, Christian and Jewish perspective – setting forth the spiritual foundation for resistance and protest in the face of immorality.   Each demand that we speak out.  It is not optional.  It is a core component.  Faith without action is meaningless.

Man-made laws are just and to be obeyed only to the degree that they comport with God’s law, the higher law.  Our Christian essayist made that point crystal clear last week when she wrote:

“Government is intended to serve as God’s servant for the common good. But when governing authorities fail—when they punish the righteous or reward the unjust—they step outside of their God-given purpose. Scripture is clear: rulers are not beyond accountability. The prophets consistently confronted leaders when they strayed from God’s justice.”

Now it is true that it is oftentimes difficult to discern the conformity of man-made laws to God’s higher standards.  People of good faith can disagree.  That is both reasonable and desirable as we collectively divine the mysteries of God’s design. Nonetheless, there are points in time when it is beyond clear that we are breaking God’s laws and the line has been crossed, as the No Kings sign declaimed.

It is frequently and accurately remarked that the current Federal administration under President Trump is chaotic.  Even those who support his policies likely would agree.

Chaotic though it may be, nonetheless there is a unifying and overarching theme.  It is this: if you are marginalized in any way, you are unmistakenly under attack.

You have likely been slurred and ridiculed.  You have probably seen benefits and protections stripped or pared back to unsustainable levels.  You may have been arrested, or you fear that it could occur for reasons unfathomable to you a year ago.  You may feel intimidated from speaking out, something you never imagined possible in this country.  You may worry about being denied due process if you are alleged to have committed an offense against the government, even a “thought” offense.  If you are an immigrant or undocumented stranger in our country, you surely worry about being separated from your family and being summarily deported.

We are becoming a land where we are constantly glancing over our shoulders.

Immediately before the Boston Common No Kings Rally, my wife and I experienced the best of humanity.  We attended the closing class of a multi-week City of Boston Program called “Immigrants Lead Boston” and I participated in a panel discussion with other representatives of Boston area community-based non-profits working to uplift and help immigrants.  We heard several teams of enthusiastic young immigrant leaders, including one of our own AFTDJ volunteers from Uganda, discuss their plans and ideas for meaningful contributions and initiatives to make Boston an even more vibrant community for all.  They understand what it means to seek the common good.

A panel discussion with representatives of Boston area community-based non-profits working to uplift and help immigrants

Recently departed Pope Francis wrote in his Joy of the Gospel Exhortation:

“I ask God to give us more politicians capable of sincere and effective dialogue aimed at healing the deepest roots – and not simply the appearances – of the evils in our world! Politics, though often denigrated, remains a lofty vocation and one of the highest forms of charity inasmuch as it seeks the common good …. I beg the Lord to grant us more politicians who are genuinely disturbed by the state of society, the people, the lives of the poor!”

Right now, our society is sorely in need of, perhaps even desperate for, the rise of Pope Francis politicians, the immigrant leaders of the Boston program, and you, people of good faith from all different traditions.  As too many have said, what we are experiencing is not normal and, as the sign said, it is not moral.

There were so many good signs at the Rallies.  One said: “Fight Truth Decay.”  I thought not of a dentist but of last week’s essay from our Islamic writer about the imperative of standing for truth and exposing falsehoods in these upside-down times.

Another that I loved, undoubtedly because of my life situation, read:

“I am a member of Grand-ifa – fighting to save democracy for my grandchildren.”

I thought this time of last week’s essay from our Jewish Rabbi about the powerful message of teaching the next generation by example to stand sturdily in the public square for the timeless Scriptural values of compassion and justice.

Lastly, I was unnerved by the sign held by one protestor.   I can’t get it out of my mind:

Hitler Didn’t Start With Camps.  He Started With:Woman holding a sign at the No Kings Rally in Boston

  • Banning Books
  • Targeting the Press
  • Blaming Immigrants
  • Creating Enemies from Neighbors
  • Controlling the Courts and Judges
  • Attacking Workers Rights
  • Spreading Lies and Conspiracy Theories
  • Using Religion as a Weapon
  • Replacing Truth With Propaganda

 

I want to tell myself that her sign is extreme, but I can’t convince myself.

As Pope Francis pleads, we must “beg” for more of a certain kind of politician, and we need to beg for more leaders like those young adults in the Immigrants Lead Boston Program, and we need to beg for more people of good faith across all segments of our great country to step forward, to speak out, to act in some way, big or small.

Pope Francis concluded his address to grassroots advocates at the 2015 World Meeting of Popular Movements in Boliva with these words:

“…In conclusion, I would like to repeat: the future of humanity does not lie solely in the hands of great leaders, the great powers and the elites. It is fundamentally in the hands of peoples and in their ability to organize. It is in their hands, which can guide with humility and conviction, this process of change.”

Change is unquestionably what is needed in our country today.

Tom Dwyer is the President and Executive Director of A Faith That Does Justice. He writes and speaks frequently about the imperatives of faith-filled social justice in building the common good and guiding our responses to political questions.

Comments

0 Comments