Staying With Christ After Easter: Prayer, Suffering, and the Father’s Gift

Signs, Reason, and the Spirit of Truth

Guided by the Good Shepherd

When protest becomes prayer: Faith as a language of resistance

Learning Courage from Peter

The Breath of Jesus and the Birth of the Church

 

 

Matthew’s Easter Vision

 

 

The Lord is not leaving us orphans

The “Real Presence” of Christ at Mass

In 2019, a Pew Research Center survey found that “nearly seven in ten Catholics (69%) say they personally believe that during Catholic Mass, the bread and wine used in Holy Communion “’are symbols of the body and blood of Jesus Christ.’ Just one-third of U.S. Catholics (31%) say they believe that “during Catholic Mass, the bread and wine actually become the body and blood of Jesus.’” The United States Conference of American Bishops reacted quickly to clarify what is meant by the “Real Presence” of Christ at Mass. Corpus Christi Sunday is an opportunity to reflect on the presence of Christ in the Mass.

It must be said, however, that, the Pew survey was flawed, allowing only two possible answers, both poorly framed: “Regardless of the official teaching of the Catholic Church, what do you personally believe about the bread and wine used for Communion? During Catholic Mass, the bread and wine…[1] Actually become the body and blood of Jesus Christ [2] Are symbols of the body and blood of Jesus Christ.” The question over-simplifies “symbol,” misunderstands “transubstantiation” of the bread and wine, and omits the rich concept of the presence of Christ. Authentic Catholic teaching on the presence of Christ in the Eucharist insists on a fourfold presence of Christ – in the people, in the Word, in the priest-presider, and in the Eucharistic elements.

It is better to focus on the Eucharist (Greek “thanksgiving”) instead of Real Presence. The New Testament has four accounts of its institution (1 Cor 11:23-25; Matt 26:26-28; Mark 14:22-24; Luke 22:17-20; cf. John 6: 32-58). From earliest times, the Eucharist was a regular part of worship and Christians referred to the elements of bread and wine as the Body and Blood of Christ. Even when Christians spoke of the elements as “symbols” or “antitypes,” there was no intention of denying the Presence. As early as the fourth century, language about the transformation of the elements became customary. Even before this period, some theologians wrote as if they believed in the persistence of the bread and wine after the consecration, whereas others wrote as though they held them to be no longer there. That same division of opinion has persisted in Western Christendom and remains a live question for some Christians, especially for heirs of the sixteenth-century Reformation. The Catholic Church, however, has always insisted on the word transubstantiation, though in recent years it has allowed alternative expressions for the same reality.

Other important aspects of the Eucharist should not be neglected. One aspect is that is a covenant meal, recalling the Lord’s choice of Israel in Exodus. The Lord chose Israel as “my treasured possession among all peoples, though all the earth is mine. You will be to me a kingdom of priests, a holy nation,” to which the people responded positively (Exod 19:5-6) The covenant was adopted at a meal in which all the people were represented (Exodus 24). That extraordinary meal is celebrated today in the Eucharist, allowing Christians to be assured of the Lord’s election of them and of his presence among them especially in eucharistic assemblies.

Unifying love

The Gospel for this Sunday is an excerpt from Jesus’s lengthy prayer just prior his death asking the Father for three precious gifts for the church: that its members always remain united, that they stand fast against the world’s hatred of them, and that they be conscious of being sent by Christ as heralds of the gospel. A report card on how Christians through the ages have heeded our Lord’s prayer might not have any clear A’s, but perhaps a few B’s and lots of Cs.

Unifying love . In the first century the church stayed united despite major division regarding the extent to which non-Jewish followers of Jesus had to adopt Jewish practices. The synod of Jerusalem deserves great credit for uniting the factions, and in the following centuries councils and church leaders succeeded in achieving clarity on potentially divisive doctrines. From the ninth centuries onward, however, the two great sees of Rome and Constantinople gradually grew apart, the final breach coming in 1054. The sixteenth century Protestant Reformation led to the further breakup of Christian unity and to the founding of churches sometimes at war with each other. Disunion continues today on the local level, but nationally and internationally, fortunately, cooperation continues.

Standing Fast against the World’s Hatred. Inevitably, Christians took their place among the shapers of modern society, especially in Europe and the Americas. Many people, however, took on the habits and customs of the powerful, so that it was sometimes difficult to see how so-called Christian leaders differed from non-Christian leaders in leading the way in peacemaking, care for the poor, and personal morality.

Consciousness of being sent. Becoming a politician is a great vocation, often difficult but still a great opportunity to serve. One can also serve in other places than in the political arena. It is often hard, however, to see Christians as a redemptive presence in the world, and to see Christians as markedly different from those outside the church.
Yet Christ’s prayer remains a powerful incentive today. Grace will be given to serve. May we be conscious of Christ’s example and command as we live our live and plan our futures.

Manifestations of life

Easter can be proclaimed in many ways. It can be proclaimed by nature when the deathly stillness of winter is reversed. A similar revitalizing charges Christ’s body. It can also be proclaimed by the Scriptures as the risen Christ speaks to his disciples. To hear the Easter proclamation today, let us turn first to nature, then to the Gospel.

Nature. St. Francis of Assisi understood how nature speaks of the resurrection in its (or her) own way. At this season of the year, plants and grass, “dead” all winter long, come to life in a riot of green and other colors. The days grow longer with brilliant and welcome sunlight. Winter’s numbing and discomforting cold retreats before the warm rays of the sun.

These are all manifestations of life. Cold, darkness, and stasis are all marks of death. Their opposites – warmth, light, and movement – are all marks of life. Nature proclaims that the life that you see in plants and animals is allied to the force that raised Jesus from the dead. The One who created the world and instituted the cycle of life and death raised Jesus from the dead to live. We are used to seeing death in the world, in the form of hatred, frustration, injustice, natural disasters, illness and death. We are less used to seeing life in the world, in the form of the triumph of the just, virtue rewarded, and the long and beautiful lives of the upright. We did not see with our own eyes the resurrection of the Jesus from the dead. We believe it, though we did not see it. But we do see the life, light, and warmth of spring with our very own eyes. That’s why nature’s proclamation of Easter is so important. When you see the reanimation of nature today, remember that it is the same life-ward thrust that brought Jesus to life and has brought you to life. Our God is a God of life, who will not let death definitively end our life and community.

John. The Gospel makes it clear we have received a great gift. We are receivers, not agents. “As the father loves me, so I also love you. Remain in my love.” We become part of the loving exchange between Father and Son that almost defines the Fourth Gospel A couple of sentences later, Jesus tells his disciples, “You are my friends (Greek philoi), no longer slaves (Greek douloi). It’s an important distinction. A slave carries out orders; a friend embraces his desires and eagerly carries them out. The Greek word for “friend,” philoi, also has a passive sense, “one who is loved,” which the English word “friend” does not quite capture. It is an attitude that Jesus has toward us, not a task we have to do. Nature and God’s biblical word remind us as the Easter season comes to an end that we have truly shared in new life.

I am the Good Shepherd

Our ancestors the Israelites suffered a terrible trauma six centuries before Jesus – the destruction of Jerusalem, its Temple, and the exile of much of its population to various cities in the Babylonian Empire. Two prophets – Jeremiah and Ezekiel – argued it was largely the failure of the kings to offer good example and exercise leadership. In speaking to the people, Ezekiel  used a common metaphor for kings, shepherd. 

In the light of past failures of shepherd, it was a bold move for Jesus to call himself a shepherd. But Jesus quotes a key sentence of Ezekiel, which rids the term of its negative history: “I myself [the Lord] will search for my sheep, and will seek them out. I will gather them . . . will feed them with good pasture…” Jesus contrasts himself with false and self-interested shepherds, whom he brands as thieves and robbers. Strong language from the mouth of Jesus, but prompted by his passionate love for the people. We know how angry we get if people we love are tricked and robbed. Jesus likewise. 

Jesus compares himself to a shepherd in two different senses. He is the shepherd who enters through the gate and leads the sheep from the sheepfold to feed in the pasture. He knows their names and calls them one by one. The sheep follow him because they recognize his voice. We have the unforgettable picture of Jesus leading the sheep. In the early church, a frequent depiction of Christ was the Good Shepherd; its function was like a crucifix today.

The second image of Christ is the gate of the sheepfold, which may surprise us. This claim reminds us of Peter’s speech in the first reading, “There is salvation in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given among mortals by which we must be saved.” We don’t know how God manages things differently for nations than ourselves, but for us Christians Jesus is the One. We should hear his voice alone, for as the gospel says, “The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy. I came that they may have life, and have it abundantly.”

Sometimes we hesitate to bring our needs to God. Why? Often the reasons are two: (1) we don’t think God is interested in us. We are too small, too unimportant; (2) we have been unfaithful in the past and can’t guarantee we won’t sin in the future. But both these attitudes are refuted by Jesus’s comparing his Shepherd’s love for us to the love Father and Son have for each other. They attend to each other, delight in each other, give themselves trustfully to each other. To say it’s “quality love” would be an understatement. It’s stronger and more consistent than anything we can imagine. So, when Jesus says to us, “I am the Good Shepherd,” he’s saying an astonishing and marvelous thing.

We are witnesses

Many of us find it difficult to maintain our joy throughout the lengthy Easter Season, much as we might like to. Don’t be surprised. There is evidence that the earliest followers of Jesus, though they had firsthand experience of those exciting days, took steps to continue their enjoyment in the Lord’s triumph and its effect on their lives. One indication is that Luke’s Gospel shows how those early followers even after their individual and group experience of the risen Lord needed to gather together and share their experiences. 

Though it would be understandable if the disciples and friends of Jesus had gone off after his death to grieve alone, Luke’s Gospel shows they remained together. The Gospel records that some of the disciples fled when Jesus was arrested. Their betrayal might have so filled them with shame that they preferred to be alone. Instead, their grief and confusion brought them together. As they gathered, Jesus comes into their midst just when they were listening to the account of the two disciples who encountered Jesus on the way to Emmaus. In that encounter, Jesus had been unrecognizable until the end of the meal. In this appearance, however, Jesus takes pain to ensure they recognize him. He shows them his hands and his feet still bearing the marks of his physical suffering. Then in full view of the disciples, he eats the baked fish. He is not a ghost; he is fully with them. 

He explains the Scriptures to them, instructing them how “everything written about me the law of Moses and in the prophets and psalms must be fulfilled.” An explanation of why the Messiah had to suffer was necessary, since the common understanding of the Messiah was that he would be triumphant and his glory widely acknowledged. Then Jesus takes a further step. What happened to him in Jerusalem cannot be limited to Jerusalem nor even to Judah. It was meant for the nations, “for the forgiveness of sins would be preached in his name to all the nations, beginning from Jerusalem.” And the disciples gathered around him are the vanguard of the preaching, “You are witnesses of these things.” In a different way than the disciples then, we are witnesses today.

Blest are those who don’t see yet believe

Today’s gospel is one of the most moving in the entire New Testament. It shows us Jesus in the midst of his disciples. You get the impression that he would rather be with them than with any other group. If there is one word that can describe this scene, it is presence, the presence of a particular person, Jesus. But there is also absence and doubt. The presence is when Jesus appears to the ten. Only ten? Yes, Judas has left the group, having betrayed Jesus into the hands of the authorities, and Thomas is absent. When Thomas returns, the ten are excited and joyful and can hardly wait to tell him, “We have seen the Lord!” But not Thomas. Perhaps he is envious that he was not there when Jesus appeared; he may have felt left out. At any rate, he says, “Unless I see the mark of the nails in his hands, and put my finger in the mark of the nails and my hand in his side, I will not believe.”  Even in Jesus’ hand-picked friends and disciples, not all is perfection.

A week after this appearance, in fact “the second Sunday in Eastertide,” Jesus appears to the eleven (now including Thomas), and he insists that Thomas touch his wounds. As he does so, Thomas addresses Jesus with the strongest and most positive title in the entire Gospel, the name used by the psalmists in addressing God, “my Lord and my God!” Jesus rebukes Thomas for not believing the apostles’ proclamation that he has been raised from the dead, and says something relevant to us: “Blest are those who don’t see yet believe.”

What are we to make of these three examples of light amid the darkness. Simply this–we believe in the rule of the risen Lord, though we often see counter-signs such as poverty, violence, and our own reluctance to trust the preaching. God’s presence is often hidden, but it is very real. And there is one further thing in the Gospel that will help us even more. Jesus breathes on his disciples and says “Peace be with you!” Using the same word for “breathe,” God breathed on Adam in the garden of Eden and brought our first ancestor to life. 

Our life is a gift of God, though we often take it for granted. He gives the church the power to forgive sins. In the sixteenth century, the Council of Trent taught that Jesus’s words authorize the sacrament of penance. The sacrament of penance is a gift to the entire church. All of us can practice Jesus’s forgiveness when we forgive others, as the prayer, the Our Father, reminds us. And each of us can be an instrument of peace, as the prayer of St. Francis reminds us. We are represented in this scene by the apostles and through them we have this privilege of bringing God’s breath into our families and the world beyond.

The Empty Tomb

Easter is the first day of the week, and the dawning of a new way of God’s presence among us in the person of His Son, Jesus Christ. Yet if we look at the Gospel the Church gives us, it seems strikingly un-celebratory. A lone woman checks out the tomb of Jesus, and notices the entrance stone rolled back. She lets the disciples know. Peter and an unnamed “other disciple whom Jesus loved” race to the tomb. The greatest morning in Christian history and these two seem more intent on getting to the tomb ahead of the other rather than to check out the tomb. 

Peter plays a pivotal role in the resurrection accounts, and the other disciple rightly lets him enter the tomb first. What the two saw was an empty tomb rather than the risen Christ. Christ was preeminently worthy of a stupendous victory celebration. No honor would have been too great, no celebration would have been too elaborate. Peter “went into the tomb and saw the burial cloths there, and the cloth that had covered his head, not with the burial cloths but rolled up in a separate place.” Peter did not know at the time what to make of the placement, “For they did not yet understand the scripture that he had to rise from the dead.” “Then the other disciple also went in, the one who had arrived at the tomb first, and he saw and believed.” Why did this disciple believe? The text does not tell us. Scholars suggest that the presence of the linens indicated that grave robbers did not steal the body, for they would not have left behind the valuable linen cloth. The scholar Sandra M. Schneiders thinks that the cloths outlined the original position of the body of the risen Christ, who passed effortlessly through them, leaving them undisturbed. If this is true, the beloved disciple put two and two together, and believed that Jesus had risen from the dead.

Reflect on this low-key scene. The disciples initially stood in front of an empty tomb, which stunned them and led them to shed their gloomy and defeatist thoughts. More was needed, of course, namely, the Spirit’s touch and personal encounter with Jesus. But they started to listen and be open and began to realize that something great had happened, even if all the details were murky. For most of us, this indirect and slow route will be our route. It begins with an “empty tomb,” not necessarily the vision of the risen Christ, but something that brings us up short. Then comes the spirit’s touch, and then the encounter with Christ, risen from the dead.

That is why we have the long Easter season–to give us time to let the empty tomb experience blossom forth into an encounter with the risen Lord who lordship is in this world now.